sites like etsy: where else to shop handmade
etsy is the biggest handmade marketplace, but it isn’t the only place to buy from makers. here are the sites like etsy worth knowing, who’s allowed to sell on each, and what to check before you buy, starting with wareby, a new etsy competitor where every shop is local.

in this post
1why look past etsy2at a glance3the sites4a local etsy5where the money goes6how to choose7questions8sourcesthe main sites like etsy are amazon handmade (artisans approved by amazon), ebay (we think it’s best for vintage and collectibles), facebook marketplace (local listings from anyone with an account) and wareby, a new etsy competitor where every shop is a verified local business within 25 miles of you. they differ most in who’s allowed to sell. if you want to know the maker is real and nearby, start with wareby: a real person checks every shop before it opens, one cart covers several makers, you pick up from the maker or get their own delivery, and there’s no service fee. wareby is new, so shops are still opening, and there may not be one near you yet.
why do shoppers look for sites like etsy?
a few reasons come up again and again:
- not everything is handmade. etsy’s rules allow items made, designed, handpicked or sourced by the seller, including items made by a production partner if the seller says so. in 2024, modern retail reported resold h&m and shein clothing and stanley tumblers listed as handmade, which etsy removed once they were flagged.
- the seller can be anywhere. etsy sells worldwide, and 26% of its sales come from outside the us. orders are usually shipped from wherever the seller is.
- it’s enormous. 5.6 million active sellers makes it hard to tell a neighbor with a kiln from a warehouse.
none of that makes etsy a bad place to shop. with 86.5 million active buyers, it still has the widest choice of handmade and vintage that ships. but if you care who made it and where, it helps to know the other places to look.
how do the sites like etsy compare?
| who sells | best for | |
|---|---|---|
| wareby | only independent local businesses, checked by a real person before they open | makers, bakers and growers within 25 miles of you |
| etsy | sellers anywhere in the world | the widest choice of handmade and vintage, shipped |
| amazon handmade | artisans approved by amazon | handmade things shipped by the maker or by amazon. no food |
| ebay | sellers of new, used and vintage things | one specific collectible or hard-to-find piece |
| facebook marketplace | anyone with a facebook account | secondhand things you pick up nearby |
| markets and fairs | whoever has a table that day | meeting the maker before you buy |
the “best for” column is our opinion. we make wareby, so weigh that.
what are the best sites like etsy?
wareby comes first because it’s ours, and because it’s the only one here that checks every seller is local. the rest are in no particular order.
- wareby. a marketplace only for verified local businesses. you see the shops within 25 miles of you: potters, candle makers, florists, home bakers. a real person checks the owner’s id, the address they sell from, and a food permit for anyone selling food. fill one cart from several shops, then pick up from the maker, get their own delivery, or have things that aren’t food shipped. what “verified local” means.
- amazon handmade. amazon’s marketplace for artisans it has approved, with orders shipped by the maker or by amazon. food isn’t allowed, so you won’t find home bakers there. wareby vs amazon handmade.
- ebay. ebay’s buyers search for specific things, so we think it’s the place for collectibles, used goods and hard-to-find vintage more than for handmade. etsy vs ebay.
- facebook marketplace. the biggest local listing board there is. anyone with a facebook account can list, and sellers type in their own location. purchase protection doesn’t cover local pickup or payments made outside checkout, so meet somewhere public and look before you pay. wareby vs facebook marketplace.
- markets and craft fairs. not a site, but still the surest way to know who made something: you’re standing in front of them. many makers take orders between markets, so ask for their shop link.
is there a local version of etsy?
that’s what wareby is. etsy shows you sellers from anywhere. wareby only shows you independent businesses within 25 miles, each one checked by a real person before it opens, with no chains, franchises or drop-shippers. for shoppers, that means:
- you know the shop is real and nearby before you order
- one cart and one checkout across several makers, with no service fee
- pickup from the maker or their own delivery, so there’s often no waiting on the mail
- food from home bakers and cooks, with the food permit checked
- the wareby promise: if an order is never ready, never delivered or never ships, you get your money back
where etsy wins: far more to choose from, shipped from anywhere to anywhere. wareby is local only and it’s new, so shops are still opening. see the shops near you. if none have opened yet, leave your email there and we’ll tell you when the first ones do. make things yourself? open your wareby shop free, or read the etsy alternatives for sellers.
does it matter where the seller is?
it changes where your money ends up. civic economics, an economic research firm, surveyed 318 businesses in 20 places between 2012 and 2022. independent retailers put 52.9% of their revenue back into the local economy (local wages, local suppliers, local services and profits spent nearby), compared with 13.6% for chain retailers.
a marketplace can’t promise that on its own, but buying from a maker in your own town keeps more of the sale there than buying from a seller who could be anywhere. where your money goes when you shop local.
which site like etsy should you use?
| if you… | start with | why |
|---|---|---|
| want to buy from makers near you | wareby | every shop is a verified local business within 25 miles |
| want bread, cookies or cakes from a home baker | wareby | home bakers sell there with their food permit checked. amazon handmade doesn’t allow food |
| don’t want to wait on shipping | wareby | pickup from the maker, or their own delivery |
| want the widest choice, shipped from anywhere | etsy | 86.5 million active buyers shop there for a reason |
| want handmade with amazon’s checkout | amazon handmade | approved artisans, shipped by the maker or by amazon |
| are hunting one specific vintage or collectible piece | ebay | its buyers and sellers deal in specific items |
| want something secondhand to pick up | facebook marketplace | huge and local, but pickups aren’t covered by purchase protection |
questions people ask
what sites are like etsy?
amazon handmade, ebay, facebook marketplace and wareby. amazon handmade sells approved artisans’ work, ebay suits vintage and collectibles, facebook marketplace is local listings from anyone, and wareby is only verified local businesses within 25 miles of you. we make wareby.
is there a new etsy competitor?
yes. wareby is a new marketplace where every shop is an independent local business, checked by a real person before it opens, and shown only to shoppers within 25 miles. it’s new, so shops are still opening. we make wareby.
is there a local version of etsy?
wareby. you only see shops within 25 miles of you, and you can pick up from the maker, get their own delivery, or have things that aren’t food shipped.
is everything on etsy handmade?
no. etsy allows items made, designed, handpicked or sourced by the seller, including items made by a production partner if the seller says so.
does wareby charge shoppers a fee?
no. there’s no service fee for shoppers on wareby.
what’s the best etsy alternative for sellers?
it depends on what you want to fix: fees, ads or finding buyers near you. our guide to etsy alternatives compares what each one takes from the same $35 sale.
sources
- etsy: creativity standards
- etsy, inc.: 2025 annual report (form 10-k)
- modern retail: sellers worry about the “amazon-ification” of etsy (2024)
- amazon seller central: amazon handmade
- amazon: sell on amazon handmade
- ebay: selling fees
- facebook help center: purchase protection
- facebook help center: your listing’s location
- civic economics: indie impact study series
- the wareby promise
we checked every fee and fact about other companies on october 12, 2026, on their own pages. fees change, so check theirs before you decide. spot something out of date? email hello@shopwareby.com and we’ll fix it.
etsy, amazon handmade, ebay and facebook marketplace are trademarks of their owners. wareby isn’t affiliated with any of them, and we make wareby, so weigh our opinions with that in mind.



